This post was written with Brandon Blom (@brandonkblom, you can check out his blog here). Brandon and I are both elementary school principals in the Roseville City School District. Before being principals, Brandon was a middle school math teacher, and I was an elementary school teacher and then a middle school ELA/History teacher. Both of us are passionate and avid readers.
What has Accelerated Reader (AR) been used for in the past at our schools?
AR has been used as an accountability system to set point goals for kids to achieve by taking quizzes that only include multiple choice questions to check for basic understanding. The points and quizzes are used to monitor if students are reading.
For one year, AR would cost Stoneridge, a school of 550 kids, $4,085. For Sargeant, 450 kids, the cost would be $3,515.
What do we want for our students?
As principals and parents we want our children to develop and continue a love of reading. We want them to enjoy reading. We want students to engage in conversation about books and topics they’ve read. We want students to be excited about what they’re reading and choose to read; not feel they have to read.
|The Stoneridge Staff all dressed up for Storybook Character Dress Up Day.|
What do some students and some teachers like about AR? AND What can we do instead?
What do some students and teacher like about AR?
Earning points creates competition →
Taking quizzes holds kids accountable → for reading and makes it easy to know if they are reading
What can we do instead?
Book Conferences with the Teacher
Padlet (See example below)
Google Forms (See example below)
Book Reviews and Commercials
|Example of 3rd Grade Google Form|
|3rd Grade Padlet Wall|
What do others say about AR?
There are many resources and articles linked below, but we also wanted to pull out a few excerpts from authors, teachers, and principals around the country.
In The Book Whisperer by Donalyn Miller, she states, “Programs like Accelerated Reader or Scholastic Reading performance counts, in which books are assigned a point value and students must complete a multiple-choice test after reading them, are the worst distortion of reading I can think of….Furthermore, shifting the purpose for reading a book toward the memorization of plot details and away from an overall appreciation for the books changes how students read.”
In a recent blog post, teacher and author Pernille Ripp stated, “We must be reading to read. Not for rewards, not for points, not for accomplishment charts, or even to move through levels. We must read to become better human beings. We must read so that we can shape the world around us.”
Jennifer LaGarde, Lead School Library Media Coordinator said: I don't know about you, but... I did not become a reader because someone held me accountable for reading. I did not become a reader because someone offered me "points" or other incentives for the quantity of books or pages I read. I did not become a reader because someone limited my reading selections to only to those titles on a certain reading level or within a specific lexile band. And I did not become a reader because someone forced me to complete reading logs, write book reports or create (and then reuse) the occasional diorama.
Stephen Krashen, educational researcher, stated, “Despite the popularity of AR, we must conclude that there is no real evidence supporting it, no real evidence that the additional tests and rewards add anything to the power of simply supplying access to high quality and interesting reading material and providing time for children to read them.”
|Brandon reading to 1st grade students|
As a school, what are you doing to develop the love of reading in both students and staff?
BB: Posters around school for teachers to write “What I am Currently Reading”
Free Book for every student
Storybook Character Dress Up Day
Principal Reads to Every Class at least 4 times a year
Reading Book Whisperer - entire staff
Collective Commitments Around Reading
RP: Staff Displays their “Hot Read” - book they’re currently reading or a favorite
Principal Reads to Every Class at least 4 times a year
Monthly Book Cart at Recess - students give a book/take a book
Surprise Guest Readers
Surprise Guest Readers
What are your personal experiences with AR?
RP: I’ll admit, as a teacher I used AR in my classroom. I tweaked it to make it work for me, but there were some things that I liked. Over the past two years I’ve been reading about reading. I’ve taken the time to ask myself what I truly want for not only my own two children but all of the students at our school. I want them to enjoy reading and develop a passion for reading that stays with them throughout their life. This leads me to the question, does AR support that desire?
I think AR can appear to create a desire to read, but it's really just a desire to earn the points and reach the goal. What if the points are gone? Will the child still want to read? What happens if there is something they want to read without points?
On a personal note, my oldest son is an avid reader and has been since 2nd grade. He loves competition so he loves earning his points to prove that he can meet his goal. At the same time, this year I saw him abandon books that he wanted to read for two reasons: there was no AR quiz and books he received as a present (that he really wanted!) were only worth one point and he didn't want to waste his time. It was a sad moment for me when I saw that because of the guidelines around AR, he was giving up on books he really wanted to read.
|Enjoying reading with a friend|
BB: I love competition. It is part of the reason I love sports. But if we are creating competition where students are losing when it comes to reading, it is wrong. Have we had students miss their AR goal and feel like a total failure? Yes we have. And any system where students feel like they are not a reader because they missed a goal is wrong, especially when they might have read plenty.
My daughter loved reading The One and Only Ivan. She had to tell me all about it everyday until she was finished. She told me it was her favorite book she had ever read. When she went to school to take the AR test she scored a 60%, she didn’t pass yet I know she could tell you everything about that book. A little while later she was talking to a friend at our house about books they liked. I didn’t hear her recommend The One and Only Ivan. I asked her why and her response was that it was just ok. I know she felt that way because she didn’t pass the AR test.
We had an author come and visit our school. His book was mainly for 3rd, 4th and 5th graders. The author did a great job talking about the writing process and then went into his newest book. Students were so excited about the book because of the way he described it. After he was done giving his presentation, he asked if there were any questions. The very first question that came up, “How many AR points is your book worth”. Depending on what answer he gave students would either still want to read it or for some the book wouldn’t be worth enough points and therefore not worth reading.
Wrapping it All Up
We know we stated it earlier but our main goal is for our students to love to read. We want students that are lifelong readers and you don’t do that by worrying about how many points a book is worth or having to answer low level multiple choice questions. Students become lifelong readers when they have choice in what they get to read, when they have adults that model a love of reading, when they get to have authentic conversations about the books they read and when they read to read and not because of rewards. When we look at cost, rewards, limiting book selection, having students take tests that no adult would ever do after they read a book, AR doesn’t make sense to us. And for all those reasons, that is why we are moving on from AR.
Articles or resources to share: